Star Wars vs Star Trek

[George1]

It works for Dr. Who!

well it works if the series is BASED on it. like i said, primeval.NOT work without time travel.

[SciWriter]

My Star Trek novel:

http://gallery.me.com/austintorney/101199

I'm not an approved Star Trek writer; it's just an episode I wanted to 'see', so I wrote it, long ago.

[Shogun]

It works for Dr. Who!

Well, what can you say, it is Dr. Who!

[siphra]

You don't understand, their radius is huge and literally makes anything and everything in the radius vanish into nothing.....and never seen again. Those warheads won't need to detonate on target, plus they can be spammed.

I dont recall the blast radius of those weapons but unless they are >> 20,000 KM each they would be detonated out of range.

[Shogun]

I dont recall the blast radius of those weapons but unless they are >> 20,000 KM each they would be detonated out of range.

No.....

But the dimension eater have that kind of range iirc.

[siphra]

No.....

But the dimension eater have that kind of range iirc.

Just looked it up, Resource says 3,000 m range (so 3km, meaning they would be destroyed long before ever getting close to blast range. And while yes, the SDF macross cannon would hurt, its apparent power is about equal to that of a BlackStone Fortress, so it is survivable by 40K ships.

[Shogun]

Just looked it up, Resource says 3,000 m range (so 3km, meaning they would be destroyed long before ever getting close to blast range. And while yes, the SDF macross cannon would hurt, its apparent power is about equal to that of a BlackStone Fortress, so it is survivable by 40K ships.

Dimension Eater have a way bigger range.....here is something....

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4gX7S8rUfnA

[Shogun]

Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann, found a good video. The laws of physics don't work.....because it is a sci-fi. I can't find a good video ( haven't gotten to that episode, I forgot if it is in the anime or the manga ) of the mech that is the size of an universe. NOTE: This video is a spoiler. 24 minutes, a full episode

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f0tqGjdGYCM

The fight is pretty much the entire episode anyways.

P.S. The "ground" they are fighting on at the fight, it is not a galaxy, it is way bigger, it is a plane created by them just to fight this battle. The galaxies were the things they threw around and 1 shotted. It is epic, watch it, the dialog is kinda funny as well. I can't take them seriously with those voice actors.

[Lord Vasago]

The transdimentional jumping in Andromeda imo is the best defnece you can get. No matter howmany 40k ship you send to intercept , It won't have any effect except extra target pratice for the andromeda. add novabombs , and a point-singularity weapon. The andromeda can just go pure guerillia style on any foo.

Jump in for a milli-sec. drop payload jump out. they wouldn't not know what hit them. It they start firing and lauch missiles they would just hit themselfs

shift your troops infrom of the queens (borg or Nids) shoot shift out. collective memory my ass. Take out the mind and all you have left are zombies lol.

[Shogun]

The Tegen Toppa Gurren Laggan is the one in the last video. The thing the size of a universe is the Super Tegen Toppa Gurren Laggan. It is in the movie ( haven't watched it ). Here is another epic scene.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hd3l1...eature=related

[siphra]

Ok, Universe size vehicles are just... well ... ok, I can't even fathom fighting those with anything due to sheer scale.

As to Andromeda Ninja jumping in and out... its not going to be so cut and dry, and singularity weapons, no sweat...

[George1]

HAHAHA,I JUST WATCHED THE NEW EPISODE AND IT WAS JUST AS AWESOME AS I EXPECTED IT TO BE!

http://www.vureel.com/video/24698/St...osts-of-Mortis

STAR WARS ROCKS!

[Shogun]

Ok, Universe size vehicles are just... well ... ok, I can't even fathom fighting those with anything due to sheer scale.

Not just that, they can pretty much make weapons out of thin air, and actually fire the big bang at somebody ( I know it doesn't make sense, it is fiction ). The COLLATERAL damage destroyed countless galaxies in gurren lagann.

[Nexarc]

As well as physically change the laws of probability just by the sheer amount of manliness the pilots radiate. Actually....reality itself can implode by the great density of awesome, which is the reason the villians wished to suppress everything they can.

Awesome anime, but it leans more towards science-fantasy than science-fiction.

[fedr808]

HAHAHA,I JUST WATCHED THE NEW EPISODE AND IT WAS JUST AS AWESOME AS I EXPECTED IT TO BE!

http://www.vureel.com/video/24698/St...osts-of-Mortis

STAR WARS ROCKS!

except for when it doesnt.

[George1]

except for when it doesnt.

you probably feel good with that claim. say what you like.

star wars STILL ROCKS

[siphra]

you probably feel good with that claim. say what you like.

star wars STILL ROCKS

Episodes 2-6 sure, the Books sure, But clone wars and episode 1 != Rocks

[George1]

Episodes 2-6 sure, the Books sure, But clone wars and episode 1 != Rocks

ok, i find all episodes nice, sure episode 1 is worse than the rest but its not that bad, lol.
the clone wars is probably the best animated series ever. the story is just awesome, the battles are just WOW.

[Trekmonster]

Babylon 5 was the greatest sci-fi series ever made but its not on the list

[George1]

Babylon 5 was the greatest sci-fi series ever made but its not on the list

i watched only a few episodes of it...ok, a lot actually, mostly of season 5. but i couldn't say its the greatest.