-
01-16-07, 01:59 AM #1is feeling caustic
- Posts
- 4,830
Actual electrostatics question
If 13 stationary source charges are placed at the vertices of a 13-sided polygon (a triskaidecagon), what is the total electric field provided by them at the geometric center of the triskaidecagon?
I have a numeric/symbolic answer but I'd like to see someone solve it to see if our results are the same, especially since explaining my way would involve appeals to geometric ideas I can't convey in ascii.
-
01-16-07, 03:19 AM #2
Are the charges identical, or arbitrary?
Is the polygon a regular polygon?
-
01-16-07, 03:53 AM #3Registered Senior Member
- Posts
- 1,613
-
01-16-07, 09:00 AM #4
Thanks CANGAS.
It is indeed natural to assume that the answers are as you suggest, but since the question is posed by SouthStar I'd rather he clarified it.
-
01-16-07, 01:05 PM #5is feeling caustic
- Posts
- 4,830
Cangas is right. Yes to both. I'd like also to see if anyone has the same ideas I do on generalizing to an n-gon (n>2).
-
01-16-07, 01:56 PM #6
By symmetry, the field at the center must be zero.
Did you mean the total electrostatic potential?
-
01-17-07, 02:43 AM #7is feeling caustic
- Posts
- 4,830
Ah yep. You're right. I had an analytic way of doing it though and Mathematica came up with ~3^-15, which is a poor excuse for 0.
I'm having trouble with this one though. You have a spherical shell of charge, radius a and surface density sigma from which a SMALL circular piece of radius b << a is removed. What is the direction and magnitude of the field at the center of the hole in the shell (ignoring the removed circular piece).
I got a field of 2*pi*sigma. I'd like to see if anyone can replicate.
-
01-17-07, 05:18 AM #8

Reply With Quote

Bookmarks