"What's Wrong With the Ten Commandments?" Article

Oxygen · Sep 19, 2006

I found this article on another website. I don't normally post huge quotes like this, but I thought it was an interesting essay. It got me to thinking. If we re-wrote the Ten Commandments, what would you put it or take out?

Critics of the Christian bible occasionally can score a point or two in discussion with the religious community by noting the many teachings in both the Old and New Testaments that encourage the bible believer to hate and to kill, biblical lessons that history proves Christians have taken most seriously. Nonetheless the bible defendant is apt to offer as an indisputable parting shot, "But don't forget the ten commandments. They are the basic bible teaching. Study the ten commandments."

Do study the ten commandments! They epitomize the childishness, the vindictiveness, the sexism, the inflexibility and the inadequacies of the bible as a book of morals.

Actually, only six of the ten commandments deal with an individual's moral conduct, which comes as a surprise to most Christians. Essentially, the first four commandments say:

1.Thou shalt have no other gods before me.

2.Thou shalt not make thee any graven images or bow down to them, and if you do I'll get you and your kids and their descendants.

3.Thou shalt not take the name of the lord in vain.

4.Keep the Sabbath holy.

The exact terminology is found in chapter five of Deuteronomy. Two other versions of the "ten commandments" can be found in the Old Testament. One version, in Exodus 20, differs slightly from the Deuteronomy version, while a third, in Exodus 34, is wildly different, containing commandments about sacrifices and offerings and ending with the teaching: "Thou shalt not seethe a kid in its mother's milk." This is the only version referred to in scriptures as the "ten commandments."

In essence, the first four commandments all scream that "the lord thy god" has an uneasy vanity, and like most dictators, must resort to threats, rather than intellectual persuasion, to promote a point of view. If there were an omnipotent god, can you imagine him or her being concerned if some poor little insignificant creature puttered around and made a graven image? Do you think that any god, possessing the modicum of good will you could expect to find in any neighbor, would want to punish children even "unto the third and fourth generation" because their fathers could not believe? How can anyone not perceive the pettiness, bluster, bombast and psychotic insecurity behind the first four commandments? We are supposed to respect this!

"Honor thy father and thy mother" is the fifth commandment, and it is, of course, an extension of the authoritarian rationale behind the first four. Honor cannot be bestowed automatically by an honest intellect. Intellectually honest people can honor only those who, in their opinion, warrant their honor. The biologic fact of fatherhood and motherhood does not in and of itself warrant honor. Until very recently parenthood was not a matter of choice. It still is a mandatory, not optional, happening for many of the world's people. Why should any child be commanded to honor, without further basis, parents who became parents by accident--who didn't even plan to have a child? All of us know children who have been abused, beaten or neglected by their parents. What is the basis for honor there? How does the daughter honor a father who sexually molests her? "Honor only those who merit your honor" would be a more appropriate teaching, and if that includes your parents, great! "Honor your children" would have been a compassionate commandment.

Commandments six through nine--thou shalt not kill, commit adultery, steal or bear false witness--obviously have merit, but even they need extensive revision. To kill in self-defense is regrettable, but it is certainly morally defensible, eminently sensible conduct. So is the administration of a shot or medication that will end life for the terminally ill patient who wishes to die.

Adultery, the subject of the seventh commandment, again raises the question of an absolute ban. For the most part fidelity in marriage is a sound rule, making for happiness; but some marriages may outlast affection. Some couples may agree to live by different rules. Until relatively recent times Christian marriages were not dissolvable except by death, so the ban of divorce coupled with the ban of adultery obviously created great distress. Adultery, it must be remembered, involves an act between consenting adults. How much more relevant and valuable it would be to have, for instance, a commandment that forbids the violent crimes of rape and incest.

"Thou shalt not steal" raises questions regarding the usefulness of a blanket condemnation, and may put squatter's rights ahead of public and private welfare. Should people who are cold or ill steal to ameliorate their situations? Should the child who is hungry steal? Surely this commandment cries for some amending clauses. One is reminded of the comment of Napoleon, who really had religion figured out: "How can you have order in a state without religion? For, when one man is dying of hunger near another who is ill of surfeit, he cannot resign himself to this difference unless there is an authority which declares, 'God wills it thus.' Religion is excellent stuff for keeping people quiet."

In general, to bear false witness is construed to mean "don't lie," and that is a valuable moral precept, except again it is stated in absolute terms. Lies have saved lives, they have preserved relationships, and every day they save hurt feelings. The truth is not always a reasonable or kind solution. Interestingly, in biblical times the dictum not to bear false witness against a neighbor was a tribal commandment and meant to apply only to persons within the tribe--it was quite all right to bear false witness against "strangers."

Finally, the tenth commandment, which riles the feminist blood, says: "Neither shalt thou desire thy neighbor's wife, neither shalt thou covet thy neighbor's house, his field, or his manservant, or his maidservant, his ox, or his ass, or anything that is thy neighbor's." In addition to rating a wife with an ox and an ass, the bible loftily overlooks the woman who might desire her neighbor's husband. Covetousness somehow does not seem like such a crime. If you can't have a comfortable house or a productive farm, what is the great harm in wishing you did? Covetousness may be nonproductive and unpretty, but to make a big, bad deal out of it is ridiculous. Bible apologists sometimes will excuse the triviality of the tenth commandment on the basis that to covet, in a more superstitious age, meant "to cast an evil eye." Someone who coveted "his neighbor's house" was purportedly casting an evil eye on that property with a view toward its destruction. Whether one accepts the apologist's definition of covet or the more popular meaning, the tenth commandment lacks real importance.

Little in Christianity is original. Most of it is borrowed, just as the celebration of Christmas was borrowed from Roman and earlier pagan times. When the "lord" supposedly wrote his commandments on two tablets of stone and delivered them to Moses (Deut. 5:22), he was only aping earlier gods: Bacchus, Zoroaster and Minos.

Reflect for a moment that almost anyone reading this nontract could write a kinder, wiser, more reasonable set of commandments than those that Christians insist we honor. Try it!
Click to expand...

Log in or Sign up to hide all adverts.

PsychoticEpisode · Sep 20, 2006

You'd think God would have had declared "Thou shalt obey these commandments" as the first on the list.

I'd also guess we're just too stupid to figure out we shouldn't be killing each other.

Log in or Sign up to hide all adverts.

Fraggle Rocker · Sep 20, 2006

Good post. Now let's work on the seven deadly sins.
Please Register or Log in to view the hidden image!

Log in or Sign up to hide all adverts.

PsychoticEpisode · Sep 20, 2006

Fraggle Rocker said:

Good post. Now let's work on the seven deadly sins.
Please Register or Log in to view the hidden image!
Click to expand...

#8 on the list but the most deadly......faith

Sarkus · Sep 20, 2006

PsychoticEpisode said:

#8 on the list but the most deadly......faith
Click to expand...

#9.... Pickled Herring! Surely wrong in any culture!!

Oxygen · Sep 20, 2006

Here's a link to an interesting site about the seven deadly sins:

http://www.whitestonejournal.com/seven_deadly_sins/

Oxygen · Sep 20, 2006

And here's a fun link on that same subject. I came out pretty low on the sin scale.

http://www.4degreez.com/misc/seven_deadly_sins.html

Trilairian · Sep 20, 2006

Oxygen said:

I found this article on another website. I don't normally post huge quotes like this, but I thought it was an interesting essay. It got me to thinking. If we re-wrote the Ten Commandments, what would you put it or take out?
Click to expand...

In some cases I prefer the book of the dead versions better than the versions that entered the biblical mythos.Though each has a couple the other does not, what tells me that the BoD(book of the dead) was the source for what was written into the bible is the fact that they are basically in the same order. Four concepts are clearly common between the two, but the Bod's I have not caused anyone's suffering was obviously inspiration for the bible's "You shall not bear false witness against your neighbor" and "You shall not covet" and the first two biblical commands I think were inspired from the Bod's first concept from which the bible's third commandment clearly derives, thus in all seven or eight commandments of the ten have been derived from Egyptian religion.

Bible
you shall have no other gods before me.
You shall not make for yourself an idol,

BoD
I have not reviled the God.
Bible
You shall not make wrongful use of the name of the Lord your God,

BoD
I have not laid violent hands on an orphan.
I have not done what the God abominates . . .

Bible
Remember the sabbath day, and keep it holy
Honor your father and your mother

BoD
I have not killed; I have not turned anyone over to a killer.
Bible
You shall not murder.

Bod
I have not caused anyone's suffering . . .

Bod
I have not copulated (illicitly); I have not been unchaste.
Bible
You shall not commit adultery.

BoD
I have not increased nor diminished the measure, I have not diminished the palm;
I have not encroached upon the fields.
I have not added to the balance weights;
I have not tempered with the plumb bob of the balance.
Bible
You shall not steal.

Bod
I have not taken milk from a child's mouth;
I have not driven small cattle from their herbage...
I have not stopped (the flow of) water in its seasons;
I have not built a dam against flowing water.
I have not quenched a fire in its time . . .
I have not kept cattle away from the God's property.
I have not blocked the God at his processions.

Bible
You shall not bear false witness against your neighbor.
You shall not covet

Log in or Sign up

"What's Wrong With the Ten Commandments?" Article

Oxygen One Hissy Kitty Registered Senior Member

Google AdSense Guest Advertisement

PsychoticEpisode It is very dry in here today Valued Senior Member

Google AdSense Guest Advertisement

Fraggle Rocker Staff Member

Google AdSense Guest Advertisement

PsychoticEpisode It is very dry in here today Valued Senior Member

Sarkus Hippomonstrosesquippedalo phobe Valued Senior Member

Oxygen One Hissy Kitty Registered Senior Member

Oxygen One Hissy Kitty Registered Senior Member

Trilairian Registered Senior Member

Share This Page

Log in or Sign up

"What's Wrong With the Ten Commandments?" Article

Oxygen One Hissy Kitty Registered Senior Member

Google AdSense Guest Advertisement

PsychoticEpisode It is very dry in here today Valued Senior Member

Google AdSense Guest Advertisement

Fraggle Rocker Staff Member

Google AdSense Guest Advertisement

PsychoticEpisode It is very dry in here today Valued Senior Member

Sarkus Hippomonstrosesquippedalo phobe Valued Senior Member

Oxygen One Hissy Kitty Registered Senior Member

Oxygen One Hissy Kitty Registered Senior Member

Trilairian Registered Senior Member

Share This Page

Useful Searches