National Day of Prayer: Federal Judge Says No

Discussion in 'Religion Archives' started by Tiassa, Apr 16, 2010.

  1. Tiassa Let us not launch the boat ... Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    37,882
    Alright, I may be ready to add U.S. Western District Senior Judge Barbara Crabb to my list of hopeful nominees for the Supreme Court. Specifically, Judge Crabb yesterday ruled that the National Day of Prayer is unconstitutional:

    A federal judge in Wisconsin ruled the National Day of Prayer unconstitutional Thursday, saying the day amounts to a call for religious action.

    U.S. District Judge Barbara Crabb wrote that the government can no more enact laws supporting a day of prayer than it can encourage citizens to fast during Ramadan, attend a synagogue or practice magic.

    "In fact, it is because the nature of prayer is so personal and can have such a powerful effect on a community that the government may not use its authority to try to influence an individual's decision whether and when to pray," Crabb wrote.

    Congress established the day in 1952 and in 1988 set the first Thursday in May as the day for presidents to issue proclamations asking Americans to pray. The Freedom From Religion Foundation, a Madison-based group of atheists and agnostics, filed a lawsuit against the federal government in 2008 arguing the day violated the separation of church and state.

    President Barack Obama's administration has countered that the statute simply acknowledges the role of religion in the United States. Obama issued a proclamation last year but did not hold public events with religious leaders as former President George W. Bush had done.

    Crabb wrote that her ruling shouldn't be considered a bar to any prayer days until all appeals are exhausted. U.S. Justice Department attorneys who represented the federal government in the case were reviewing the ruling Thursday afternoon, agency spokesman Charles Miller said. He declined further comment.

    Obama spokesman Matt Lehrich said in an e-mail to The Associated Press the president still plans to issue a proclamation for the next prayer day.

    "As he did last year, President Obama intends to recognize a National Day of Prayer," Lehrich said.


    (Richmond)

    Um ... hallelujah?
    ____________________

    Notes:

    Richmond, Todd. "Federal judge rules Day of Prayer unconstitutional". Associated Press. April 15, 2010. SeattlePI.com. April 16, 2010. http://www.seattlepi.com/national/1110ap_us_day_of_prayer.html
     
  2. Google AdSense Guest Advertisement



    to hide all adverts.
  3. sandy Banned Banned

    Messages:
    7,926
    Yeah, a whole MONTH for black history but not one day for prayer. Nice.
     
  4. Google AdSense Guest Advertisement



    to hide all adverts.
  5. Tiassa Let us not launch the boat ... Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    37,882
    Show your ... uh ... true colors?

    Telling. Says something about your criteria, eh?

    Ever hear of something called the First Amendment to the Constitution of the United States? There's nothing that says Congress cannot declare a Religious History Month. And, hey, I'd even be down with that. Americans are generally clueless about religion, including their own.
     
  6. Google AdSense Guest Advertisement



    to hide all adverts.
  7. Sarkus Hippomonstrosesquippedalo phobe Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    10,353
    Wow - I prayed so hard for this day!

    Please Register or Log in to view the hidden image!

     
  8. Tiassa Let us not launch the boat ... Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    37,882
    Not over yet

    Well, it's not over yet. We'll have to see about the composition of the Supreme Court after Stevens' replacement is confirmed.

    Keep praying, I guess.
     
  9. Grim_Reaper I Am Death Destroyer of Worlds Registered Senior Member

    Messages:
    1,349
    I am all for a National day of Prayer as long as it can be followed by a national day of you gotta be kidding.
     
  10. Tiassa Let us not launch the boat ... Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    37,882
    Perhaps something of more apparent utility?

    How about a National Day of Objective Consideration?
     
  11. Sarkus Hippomonstrosesquippedalo phobe Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    10,353
    National Day of Obeying the Laws of Probability?
     
  12. Cowboy My Aim Is True Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    3,707
    I think both are inappropriate, but for different reasons. One involves the 1st Amendment; the other, the 14th.
     
  13. CutsieMarie89 Zen Registered Senior Member

    Messages:
    3,485
    Why is this issue even big enough to go to court? No one makes you pray on national prayer day and no one bans all other races' history during the month of February. If you don't like it don't particpate.
     
  14. Pandaemoni Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    3,634
    I agree. The only argument is that it "promotes" religion over non-religion, because it sure doesn't mandate anything. But promotion of religion in a generic way is surely more noticeable on the money of the United States, and that seems to survive challenges.
     
  15. sandy Banned Banned

    Messages:
    7,926
  16. superstring01 Moderator

    Messages:
    12,110
    Duh. He's a politician. More importantly, he knows full well that the SCOTUS--which obsesses about 1st and 14th amendments--will toss it out. He can sit back, play the game, make bitchy Christian fundamentalists happy for a second, while knowing full well that justice will be done and the Constitution will be upheld.

    I mean, what the hell could be clearer: "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion. . ."

    ~String
     
  17. Doreen Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    4,101
    I wonder if they'll get around to the pledge of allegiance. It has 'under god' in it, not that this concerns me as much as the little ceremony.
     
  18. soullust Registered Senior Member

    Messages:
    1,380
    yay more national holidays,

    yippee more days ppl sit on there asses, getting paid, forcing prices up because of lost revenue...

    God help us, were either getting really stunned or, we want to become poverty stricken countries with only the rich being able to afford the joys and necessities of life...:shrug:
     
  19. Asguard Kiss my dark side Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    23,049
    hey, you could replace it with this

    Please Register or Log in to view the hidden image!



     
  20. superstring01 Moderator

    Messages:
    12,110
    Is the pledge legally observed?

    ~String
     
  21. Norsefire Salam Shalom Salom Registered Senior Member

    Messages:
    11,529
    I wonder, can states pass their own official religions? Or does that law apply to state and federal government?


    And why does no one fuss about the State constitutions' having "God" in them?


    -------------
    Alabama 1901, Preamble. We the people of the State of Alabama, invoking the
    favor and guidance of Almighty God, do ordain and establish the following
    Constitution ..

    Alaska 1956, Preamble. We, the people of Alaska, grateful to God and to
    those who founded our nation and pioneered this great land ..

    Arizona 1911, Preamble. We, the people of the State of Arizona, grateful to
    Almighty God for our liberties, do ordain this Constitution...

    Arkansas 1874, Preamble. We, the people of the State of Arkansas, grateful
    to Almighty God for the privilege of choosing our own form of government...

    California 1879, Preamble. We, the People of the State of California,
    grateful to Almighty God for our freedom .

    Colorado 1876, Preamble. We, the people of Colorado, with profound reverence
    for the Supreme Ruler of Universe .

    Connecticut 1818, Preamble. The People of Connecticut, acknowledging with
    gratitude the good Providence of God in permitting them to enjoy ...

    Delaware 1897, Preamble. Through Divine Goodness all men have, by nature,
    the rights of worshipping and serving their Creator according to the
    dictates
    of
    their consciences .

    Florida 1845, Preamble. We, the people of the State of Florida, grateful to
    Almighty God for our constitutional liberty ... establish this
    Constitution...

    Georgia 1777, Preamble. We, the people of Georgia, relying upon protection
    and guidance of Almighty God, do ordain and establish this Constitution...

    Hawaii 1959, Preamble. We, the people of Hawaii, Grateful for Divine
    Guidance . establish this Constitution

    Idaho 1889, Preamble. We, the people of the State of Idaho, grateful to
    Almighty God for our freedom, to secure its blessings ..

    Illinois 1870, Preamble. We, the people of the State of Illinois, grateful
    to Almighty God for the civil, political and religious liberty which He hath
    so
    long permitted us to enjoy and looking to Him for a blessing on our
    endeavors
    .

    Indiana 1851, Preamble. We, the People of the State of Indiana, grateful to
    Almighty God for the free exercise of the right to chose our form of
    government
    ..

    Iowa 1857, Preamble. We, the People of the State of Iowa, grateful to the
    Supreme Being for the blessings hitherto enjoyed, and feeling our dependence
    on Him for a continuation of these blessings ... establish this Constitution

    Kansas 1859, Preamble. We, the people of Kansas, grateful to Almighty God
    for our civil and religious privileges . establish this Constitution.

    Kentucky 1891, Preamble. We, the people of the Commonwealth of grateful to
    Almighty God for the civil, political and religious liberties...

    Louisiana 1921, Preamble. We, the people of the State of Louisiana, grateful
    to Almighty God for the civil, political and religious liberties we enjoy ..

    Maine 1820, Preamble. We the People of Maine .. acknowledging with grateful
    hearts the goodness of the Sovereign Ruler of the Universe in affording us
    an opportunity ... and imploring His aid and direction

    Maryland 1776, Preamble. We, the people of the state of Maryland, grateful
    to Almighty God or our civil and religious liberty...

    Massachusetts 1780, Preamble. We...the people of Massachusetts,
    acknowledging with grateful hearts, the goodness of the Great Legislator of
    the
    Universe...in the course of His Providence, an opportunity and devoutly
    imploring His
    direction ...

    Michigan 1908, Preamble. We, the people of the State of Michigan, grateful
    to Almighty God for the blessings of freedom ... establish this Constitution

    Minnesota, 1857, Preamble. We, the people of the State of Minnesota,
    grateful to God for our civil and religious liberty, and desiring to
    perpetuate
    its
    blessings

    Mississippi 1890, Preamble. We, the people of Mississippi in convention
    assembled, grateful to Almighty God, and invoking His blessing on our work.

    Missouri 1845, Preamble. We, the people of Missouri, with profound reverence
    for the Supreme Ruler of the Universe, and grateful for His goodness ..
    establish this Constitution ..

    Montana 1889, Preamble. We, the people of Montana, grateful to Almighty God
    for the blessings of liberty establish this Constitution ..

    Nebraska 1875, Preamble. We, the people, grateful to Almighty God for our
    freedom .. establish this Constitution

    Nevada 1864, Preamble. We the people of the State of Nevada, grateful to
    Almighty God for our freedom . establish this Constitution ..

    New Hampshire 1792, Part I. Art. I. Sec. V. Every individual has a natural
    and unalienable right to worship God according to the dictates of his own
    conscience .

    New Jersey 1844, Preamble. We, the people of the State of New Jersey,
    grateful to Almighty God for civil and religious liberty which He hath so
    long permitted us to enjoy, and looking to Him for a blessing on our
    endeavors
    .

    New Mexico 1911, Preamble. We, the People of New Mexico, grateful to
    Almighty God for the blessings of liberty ..

    New York 1846, Preamble. We, the people of the State of New York, grateful
    to Almighty God for our freedom, in order to secure its blessings .

    North Carolina 1868, Preamble. We the people of the State of North Carolina,
    grateful to Almighty God, the Sovereign Ruler of Nations, for our civil,
    political, and religious liberties, and acknowledging our dependence upon
    Him for the continuance of those

    North Dakota 1889, Preamble. We, the people of North Dakota, grateful to
    Almighty God for the blessings of civil and religious liberty, do ordain...

    Ohio 1852, Preamble. We the people of the state of Ohio, grateful to
    Almighty God for our freedom, to secure its blessings and to promote our
    common
    ..

    Oklahoma 1907, Preamble. Invoking the guidance of Almighty God, in order to
    secure and perpetuate the blessings of liberty ... establish this

    Oregon 1857, Bill of Rights, Article I. Section 2. All men shall be secure
    in the Natural right, to worship Almighty God according to the dictates of
    their consciences .

    Pennsylvania 1776, Preamble. We, the people of Pennsylvania, grateful to
    Almighty God for the blessings of civil and religious liberty, and humbly
    invoking His guidance

    Rhode Island 1842, Preamble. We the People of the State of Rhode Island
    grateful to Almighty God for the civil and religious liberty which He hath
    so long permitted us to enjoy, and looking to Him for a blessing

    South Carolina, 1778, Preamble. We, the people of the State of South
    Carolina grateful to God for our liberties, do ordain and establish this
    Constitution

    South Dakota 1889, Preamble. We, the people of South Dakota, grateful to
    Almighty God for our civil and religious liberties . establish this

    Tennessee 1796, Art. XI.III. That all men have a natural and indefeasible
    right to worship Almighty God according to the dictates of their
    conscience...

    Texas 1845, Preamble. We the People of the Republic of Texas, acknowledging,
    with gratitude, the grace and beneficence of God

    Utah 1896, Preamble. Grateful to Almighty God for life and liberty, we
    establish this Constitution .

    Vermont 1777, Preamble. Whereas all government ought to ... enable the
    individuals who compose it to enjoy their natural rights, and other
    blessings which the Author of Existence has bestowed on man ...

    Virginia 1776, Bill of Rights, XVI ... Religion, or the Duty which we owe
    our Creator . can be directed only by Reason ... and that it is the mutual
    duty
    of all to practice Christian Forbearance, Love and Charity towards each
    other
    ...

    Washington 1889, Preamble. We the People of the State of Washington,
    grateful to the Supreme Ruler of the Universe for our liberties, do ordain
    this
    Constitution .

    West Virginia 1872, Preamble. Since through Divine Providence we enjoy the
    blessings of civil, political and religious liberty, we, the people of West
    Virginia .. reaffirm our faith in and constant reliance upon God .

    Wisconsin 1848, Preamble. We, the people of Wisconsin, grateful to Almighty
    God for our freedom, domestic tranquility

    Wyoming 1890, Preamble. We, the people of the State of Wyoming, grateful to
    God for our civil, political, and religious liberties ... establish this
    Constitution .


    source: http://www.truthorfiction.com/rumors/g/god-constitutions.htm
     
  22. Tiassa Let us not launch the boat ... Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    37,882
    What I wonder ....

    There are Supreme Court rulings to illuminate such questions. And the answer is pretty much, "No, they can't."

    I'll tell you what I wonder, though: I wonder why so many people—it's not just you, Norse—ask certain questions without having researched possible answers. Or is it that people have become so literal-minded that they cannot infer the answer from the various related outcomes before the Court?

    I would guess that nobody has gotten around to it yet. And it's a bit harder an argument to make, for lesser gains in the end. In 1776, or 1911, sure, people believed in God, and thanked divinity or invoked it as witness to their state constitutions. But that's as far as it goes. What would be the point of censoring people who are long dead? There are far more vital issues to consider where state and church are concerned.
     
  23. Norsefire Salam Shalom Salom Registered Senior Member

    Messages:
    11,529
    So people don't believe in God today, Tiassa?
     

Share This Page