|
|
View Full Version : sandy's Immigration Ideology Breaks an Specific Commandment
TruthSeeker 07-11-07, 01:20 PM Exodus 22:21
"21 "Do not mistreat an alien or oppress him, for you were aliens in Egypt. "
http://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Exodus%2022%20:21;&version=31;
Good going girl....:rolleyes:
spidergoat 07-11-07, 01:35 PM Holy crap, dude. Good find.
Gondolin 07-11-07, 01:54 PM Nah that the OT.
It's true... she'll pick and choose.
mikenostic 07-11-07, 01:55 PM It's true... she'll pick and choose.
Then she's going to accuse you all of making personal attacks against her.
Star_Kindler 07-11-07, 02:10 PM Question: Does she have a policy involving LEGAL immigrants, or is it ILLEGAL immigrants?
If it's the former, THEN she's violating that commandment. If it's the latter, then the bible doesn't exactly apply. The bible has PLENTY of punishments to hand out to those who break the law (as seen in the other thread directed at her).
Just curious.
Challenger78 07-11-07, 02:18 PM Everyones got their secrets.. nice find..
Question: Does she have a policy involving LEGAL immigrants, or is it ILLEGAL immigrants?
If it's the former, THEN she's violating that commandment. If it's the latter, then the bible doesn't exactly apply. The bible has PLENTY of punishments to hand out to those who break the law (as seen in the other thread directed at her).
Just curious.
Were the aliens in Egypt legal or illegal?
And by the same token, what does the Bible say about the massacre of the Native Americans by the colonists?
mikenostic 07-11-07, 02:20 PM Were the aliens in Egypt legal or illegal?
I dunno, let's go find their corpses and check to see if they had their Visas. :D
I dunno, let's go find their corpses and check to see if they had their Visas. :D
I've been watching Stargate and I'm pretty sure they were illegal.:p
SetiAlpha6 07-11-07, 02:23 PM Exodus 22:21
"21 "Do not mistreat an alien or oppress him, for you were aliens in Egypt. "
http://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Exodus%2022%20:21;&version=31;
Good going girl....:rolleyes:
:eek: See, there really are ALIENS!!! The Bible says so!!! ;)
Now it all kinda makes sense!
mikenostic 07-11-07, 02:24 PM I've been watching Stargate and I'm pretty sure they were illegal.:p
Oh well in that case, let's take the stargate to their home planet and check the peeps themselves. Maybe we could put some inter-solar system pressure on that planet's gub'mint to crack down on illegal emigration.
spidergoat 07-11-07, 02:25 PM There were no national borders as we know them today. The lesson seems clear, though.
Aliens are aliens. Note that you have to put a qualifier in front of the word "alien" to differentiate illegal from legal.
If the bible says "alien" then surely it means all?
Presumably that includes A.L.F. as well?
Star_Kindler 07-11-07, 02:31 PM [QUOTE=S.A.M.;1469615]Were the aliens in Egypt legal or illegal?[\QUOTE]
Legal for the time period. They were made into slaves. They didn't like it very much, and it's sort of "be better 'hosts' to them than the Egyptians were to you.
Also, you don't need a qualifier if you're talking about normal immigrants, and you don't generally use the term alien by itself unless you're referring to legal immigrants.
Or extraterrestrials.
TruthSeeker 07-12-07, 01:26 AM Question: Does she have a policy involving LEGAL immigrants, or is it ILLEGAL immigrants?
If it's the former, THEN she's violating that commandment. If it's the latter, then the bible doesn't exactly apply. The bible has PLENTY of punishments to hand out to those who break the law (as seen in the other thread directed at her).
Just curious.
Not really. the verse doesn't specify at all! Were the people God led out of Egypt illegal aliens? Think about it.
God only said "aliens".
TruthSeeker 07-12-07, 01:28 AM Note: "alien" also mean "stranger", as in the word "alienated". ;)
Read-Only 07-12-07, 02:20 AM Note: "alien" also mean "stranger", as in the word "alienated". ;)
Precisely! There are a lot of people speaking here with little knowledge of what they're talking about. They were aliens (strangers) in Egypt only because they had been captured and taken there as slaves. None of them "went" because they chose to.
I cannot speak for Sandy or anyone else, for that matter but here's my stand on the current situation: I believe ALL illegal aliens should be deported, regardless of what country they came from. At the same time, I've got no problem at all with legal aliens - again, regardless what country they came from. In fact, I'm very much on their side and willing to help them (and I've already done so).
No Christian takes the OT rules seriously. I mean, have you actually read them? They would all have to get circumcised, stop eating pork, and women wouldn’t be able to live in the same house as their husband when they were menstruating. Men would be obligated to marry their sister-in-law if their brother died (don't worry, it's fine if you're already married - polygamy is allowed), and people would be stoned to death for all sorts of things. Christians always just either pretend that those rules aren't there, or try to rationalize why they shouldn't have to follow them.
Sandy has already said very explicitly that she believes in OT "eye for an eye" justice and that she wishes to defend herself and fight against evil doers. That's a direct violation of Jesus' own explicit NT commands, which is presumably much worse.
welcome to sandyforums.com - ha ha ha...you made some impression Sandy.
mikenostic 07-12-07, 09:56 AM welcome to sandyforums.com - ha ha ha...you made some impression Sandy.
Just like George W. Bush has made an impression on this country...and the world for that matter.
Not every impression is a good one, John.
I've also noticed that once someone makes a post that 'personally attacks :bawl:' her in a thread, she doesn't post in that thread anymore. Notice how she hasn't posted in this thread yet.
Read-Only 07-12-07, 10:42 AM No Christian takes the OT rules seriously. I mean, have you actually read them? They would all have to get circumcised, stop eating pork, and women wouldn’t be able to live in the same house as their husband when they were menstruating. Men would be obligated to marry their sister-in-law if their brother died (don't worry, it's fine if you're already married - polygamy is allowed), and people would be stoned to death for all sorts of things. Christians always just either pretend that those rules aren't there, or try to rationalize why they shouldn't have to follow them.
Sorry, Nasser, but that's a gross generalization that does NOT apply to most real Christians. Yes, there are splinter groups that hold to some of that stuff but it's far from mainstream. For the greater majority, the OT is just an explanation of how things USED to be and every bit of it has been superseded by the NT. They consider NONE of those old laws/rules to be in effect today.
Sorry, Nasser, but that's a gross generalization that does NOT apply to most real Christians. Yes, there are splinter groups that hold to some of that stuff but it's far from mainstream. For the greater majority, the OT is just an explanation of how things USED to be and every bit of it has been superseded by the NT. They consider NONE of those old laws/rules to be in effect today.
This is what I was talking about when I said "Christians always just either pretend that those rules aren't there, or try to rationalize why they shouldn't have to follow them."
You appear to have successfully rationalized why you don’t need to follow the OT law, at least to your own satisfaction. Congratulations! I hope you enjoy eating your pork and not having to marry your sister-in-law.
Of course if you really want to get into it, Jesus himself explicitly said that he did not come to abolish the old laws. There were some specific laws that he changed, but he never said anything to indicate that he was throwing out all the OT rules. Many Christians believe that the OT rules no longer apply, but there is nothing in the Bible to support that assertion and indeed Jesus' own words seem to explicitly contradict that.
TruthSeeker 07-12-07, 11:04 AM :D :p
Exodus 22:21
"21 "Do not mistreat an alien or oppress him, for you were aliens in Egypt. "
http://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Exodus%2022%20:21;&version=31;
Good going girl....:rolleyes:Who is mistreating or oppressing aliens?
TruthSeeker 07-12-07, 11:08 AM sandy
Read-Only 07-12-07, 11:26 AM This is what I was talking about when I said "Christians always just either pretend that those rules aren't there, or try to rationalize why they shouldn't have to follow them."
You appear to have successfully rationalized why you don’t need to follow the OT law, at least to your own satisfaction. Congratulations! I hope you enjoy eating your pork and not having to marry your sister-in-law.
Of course if you really want to get into it, Jesus himself explicitly said that he did not come to abolish the old laws. There were some specific laws that he changed, but he never said anything to indicate that he was throwing out all the OT rules. Many Christians believe that the OT rules no longer apply, but there is nothing in the Bible to support that assertion and indeed Jesus' own words seem to explicitly contradict that.
Nope, it's a matter of interpretation and the majority seem to agree on the one that says the OT is dead and no longer of any effect.
Christ actually said that he came not to destroy the law but to fulfill it. And that's quite a bit different from perpetuating it. The law had prophesied his coming - and it was in that respect that he he fulfilled it.
Paul clearly said that the law had been nailed to a tree - meaning 'killed', become dead. There is also discussion about when a new testament is given it's brought into force by the death of the testator - and when that happens, the original testament ( a will) no longer is in force.
Peter also made it quite clear that he understood from his vision of the sheet that NO food was any longer considered taboo - that includes pork and everything else.
As I said before, only a few groups actually think ANY of the old laws/rules still apply today. Tell me - how long has it been since you saw anyone sacrificing a bullock or dove and sprinkling it's blood around? :D
TruthSeeker 07-12-07, 11:33 AM The original rules of the OT were laid out specifically so that the Jews could survive through the desert. Once they found their new home, many of the rules of the desert did not apply anymore. Some of them would still apply though. For instance, eating pork is still not good for you because they have a very dirty kind of meat. Whenever they eat something toxic, it stays in the meat, which we then consume. That's why God told them not to eat pork. He also gave the Jews rules of hygene. At the times of the bubonic plague, the Jews were the only ones that were surviving in great numbers. That's because they followed the hygene rules God sent to them. Once people realized that those rules are important, they were more broadly incoporated in our societies. That's when sanitation was born.
I hope I have educated you. ;)
Nope, it's a matter of interpretation and the majority seem to agree on the one that says the OT is dead and no longer of any effect.
Yeah, like I said. You have rationalized why you no longer need to follow the OT laws. Great. Personally I think that your rationalization involves some pretty complicated mental gymnastics (like assuming that when Jesus said "laws" he was talking about prophecies rather than rules), but it doesn't really matter. Since I don't believe in any of it myself, I'm not really invested in any particular interpretation and I don't really care.
Read-Only 07-12-07, 11:52 AM The original rules of the OT were laid out specifically so that the Jews could survive through the desert. Once they found their new home, many of the rules of the desert did not apply anymore. Some of them would still apply though. For instance, eating pork is still not good for you because they have a very dirty kind of meat. Whenever they eat something toxic, it stays in the meat, which we then consume. That's why God told them not to eat pork. He also gave the Jews rules of hygene. At the times of the bubonic plague, the Jews were the only ones that were surviving in great numbers. That's because they followed the hygene rules God sent to them. Once people realized that those rules are important, they were more broadly incoporated in our societies. That's when sanitation was born.
I hope I have educated you. ;)
Most of that is pretty accurate, however the part about pork is bit off the mark. There wasn't really that much toxic material available to them back then. The real problem came from trichinosis and was a very frequent problem among people who did eat pork during that period (and even now) when it hasn't been cooked sufficiently.
Read-Only 07-12-07, 11:55 AM Yeah, like I said. You have rationalized why you no longer need to follow the OT laws. Great. Personally I think that your rationalization involves some pretty complicated mental gymnastics (like assuming that when Jesus said "laws" he was talking about prophecies rather than rules), but it doesn't really matter. Since I don't believe in any of it myself, I'm not really invested in any particular interpretation and I don't really care.
No, that's not just MY rationalization - it's pretty widely understood that way by the vast majority of Christians.
And not to worry, I was simply commenting on what I saw was a misunderstanding - I'm not 'pushing' anything and that's really all I had to say about the topic.
TruthSeeker 07-12-07, 12:49 PM Most of that is pretty accurate, however the part about pork is bit off the mark. There wasn't really that much toxic material available to them back then. The real problem came from trichinosis and was a very frequent problem among people who did eat pork during that period (and even now) when it hasn't been cooked sufficiently.
Huuummm... ok. I stand corrected. But nowdays they are also full of toxic stuff. ;)
Exodus 22:21
"21 "Do not mistreat an alien or oppress him, for you were aliens in Egypt. "
http://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Exodus%2022%20:21;&version=31;
Good going girl....:rolleyes:
"Sandy's ideology" does not involve mistreating or oppressing these criminals. She asks for justice.
TruthSeeker 07-14-07, 11:28 PM she said their asses must be fried. And I'm QUOTING her....
|