Street Harrassment.!!!

Discussion in 'Ethics, Morality, & Justice' started by cluelusshusbund, Oct 30, 2014.

?

What is the main reason you thank Men behave like they did in the OP video.???

  1. Nature

  2. Nurture

  3. Other (please discuss)

Results are only viewable after voting.
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. sculptor Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    8,476
    Please list the individual 3 comments that seemed the most to evidence "harassment".

    .............
    .3% does not, repeat NOT = "all the time".
     
  2. Google AdSense Guest Advertisement



    to hide all adverts.
  3. cluelusshusbund + Public Dilemma + Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    8,000
    @ zqmc an James R:::

    Do you thank men are inherently more prone (nature) to this type of behavior than women.???
     
  4. Google AdSense Guest Advertisement



    to hide all adverts.
  5. Tiassa Let us not launch the boat ... Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    37,893
    Part the First

    He's just jealous.

    • • •​

    Maybe it would take you ten hours to find someone to harass you.

    Meanwhile, here is real prevention advocacy:

    While many harassers only harass women when they are alone or they harass women in such a way that no one else realizes what is happening, there are many times when they do blatantly harass women in front of others. Over and over women who have been harassed felt shocked or betrayed when no one around stopped to help.

    Having a bystander say or do something could make a big difference in ending the harassment scenario, helping the woman not feel alone and safe, and making it clear that the harassing behavior is socially unacceptable ....

    .... There are many barriers that keep people, especially men, from preventing and intervening in street harassment and other incidents as often as they could. For example, if there are several other people around, the “bystander effect” may mean that each person expects the other to respond or that if no one responds, there is no need to or it must be inappropriate to do so. Other reasons for doing nothing may be because the a person is unsure if the behavior is unwelcome, doesn't want to assume the person can't take care of themselves, doesn't know what to do, and/or fears the perpetrator will turn on them.

    While these are legitimate concerns, since intervention often can make a difference, the benefits may out weigh the negatives. To learn more, consider attending workshops by groups like Men Can Stop Rape and Mentors in Violence Prevention (MVP).

    Other resources include:

    Men Can Stop Rape's Where Do You Stand campaign

    Know Your Power Campaign & University of New Hampshire article “Sexual Violence Prevention Through Bystander Education: An Experimental Evaluation“

    Hollaback's bystander campaign “I've Got Your Back”

    Brian Martin's “Men: Help stop public harassment“

    Jackson Katz's The Macho Paradox: Why Some Men Hurt Women and How All Men Can Help

    Todd Denny's Unexpected Allies: Men Who Stop Rape

    Martha Langelan's Back Off! How to Confront and Stop Sexual Harassment and Harassers (see chapter 8: “Not All Men Harass: Men as Allies for Women”)

    R. W. Connell's Masculinities

    Michael S. Kimmel's Manhood in America: A Cultural History

    Michael Kaufman and Michael Kimmel's book The Guy's Guide to Feminism

    Bryon Hurt's film “Hip-Hop: Beyond Beats and Ryhmes“

    Men Can Stop Rape

    Man Up Campaign

    (Stop Street Harassment (↱))
    Meanwhile, Marly-Pierre Louis (↱) of the Brooklyn Movement Center noted last year:

    During our Anti-Street Harassment chalk party last week, Anthonine and I spoke to guys, young and old about why it's wrong to harass women in the streets. It was both entertaining and sobering to hear the many different ways they defended their right to engage in this behavior. More importantly however, it was enlightening. It made it clear that there is a huge disconnect on what is and isn't appropriate language to use with strangers. Men seemed genuinely shocked and confused that the way they spoke to women in the streets was considered harassment. It made it clear that we have our work cut out for us and that ongoing inter-gender and intergenerational dialogue must be the cornerstone of our anti-street harassment work. This article is an attempt to address that confusion.

    Almost every man we spoke to felt the remarks made to women in the streets were “harmless” and were an attempt at being neighborly. When we asked whether they were similarly neighborly to other men, their defense fell apart. They pointed out the absurdity of infringing on someone's personal space in public in that way. Yet when we pointed out that these gender-based unsolicited remarks are street harassment by definition, they adamantly disagreed. While they were difficult, we realized that each one of these conversations was a step towards a harassment free neighborhood.

    Sarah Pederson (↱) of The Siren at University of North Carolina is also part of the Hollaback movement:

    I then realized that I'm not the only person who has had to deal with harassing words from men I don't know—and men I do know. I'm not the only person who changes my outfit based on where I plan to walk that day, who plans my route to avoid places where I've been harassed before, who has become hyperaware of my surroundings, who has been conditioned to fear men as threats to my safety. These are actions and thoughts I engage in almost subconsciously—they have become a normalized part of my daily life.

    Acknowledging the sexism and misogyny still ever-present in our society is half the battle—these are painful realities that we try to bury deep. We minimize harassment and pretend that it isn't as much of a problem as it is. Yet most women—and many men—feel fear and discomfort simply while walking down the street. I think of myself as a strong woman, and I used to think that meant I shouldn't let something like “catcalling” get to me—that if I simply ignored such actions, they couldn't hurt me. But being a strong person is about standing up for yourself and others who have been hurt. It's about asserting your rights and dignity as a human being. It's about calling out people who aren't being held accountable for their actions.

    I've tried to avoid people, places, and the problem of catcalling. Now, I want to reclaim my right and everyone's right to a life free of fear, intimidation, and harassment ....

    .... Street harassment is not about giving someone a compliment.

    You give a friend a compliment (Cool shoes!) or compliment someone you've struck up a conversation with (You have such an interesting perspective on feminism). You give people compliments to empower them, show them respect, or enter into a sense of community with them.

    Street harassment, on the other hand, is a social tool used to assert dominance and control over others in public spaces. This is the opposite of a compliment—the target of harassment feels inferior, disrespected, and unwelcome. The relative freedom of women to move about in public spaces is actually a fairly recent phenomenon. The mobility of women is still severely restricted in parts of the world today. Taken in context, street harassment is part of a series of daily micro-assaults in the lives of women meant to remind them of their “true place” in the social hierarchy.

    It is important to recognize that many men who engage in harassment may not be aware of the harm they cause by saying something as seemingly benign as “Smile, you're beautiful!” Despite any good intentions, men who engage in such behavior deny the harmful impact of their controlling actions and need to seriously examine the roots of their motivation to tell another person what to think of her appearance and express her emotions.

    Furthermore, we need to cultivate a greater consciousness around the culture of male entitlement that street harassment perpetuates. These are not isolated events that exist in a vacuum, but rather actions connected to a wider societal permissiveness towards gender-based violence.

    End Part I
     
  6. Google AdSense Guest Advertisement



    to hide all adverts.
  7. Tiassa Let us not launch the boat ... Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    37,893
    Part the Second

    And as much as we might loathe the actual word "hollaback", it turns out to be effective. Consider the idea of a woman groped in a public place, who also feels empowered enough to get a photograph of her assailant, relying on self-defense training and the hope that the fact of being in a crowded area means that there is at least someone in the area who isn't like you, Sculptor. Now imagine taking the photo to the police, who already have a reputation for literally laughing off sexual assault complaints, and finding them uninterested. So she goes full hollaback, posting the photo and story to social media, which in turn creates enough public outrage that the police department sighs, makes a couple of excuses for their inaction, and says they'll look into it. Now imagine that the social media campaign happens to have landed in the right place, among other things, and the police department gets a call from the state corrections department, who advises them that they recognize the alleged groper, that he is a Level 3 sex offender, and this is where you should be able to find him unless he's violating his parole.

    It shouldn't require public humiliation of a police department and a call from corrections wondering why you're not going after a Level 3 offender.

    I'll recycle a point or two (↱) here:

    • I don't know how many times you, as a man, have had someone walk along beside you for minutes at a time trying to convince you to let him stick his penis inside you. Just sayin', man. Doesn't happen to me, and I happen to be gay. And honestly, man, how many times do you really think that's happened to Beckel?

    • If the only way you can contact a woman is by making her uncomfortable, you're doing it wrong. The only reason we might find to even consider accommodating that sort of conduct is if society concludes that male chauvinist stupidity really is a disability. And come on, let's face it, that ain't gonna happen.​

    And I would also remind that this is the sort of behavior society tells women to avoid. You know, because it's their own responsibility to prevent some random man somewhere from behaving inappropriately and dangerously. In that way, it's kind of a trap that pretty much defines rape culture: It's your job, ladies, to prevent men from treating you this way, but, hey, don't be such a cold bitch about it, eh?

    Your advocacy, Sculptor, is noted.
    ____________________

    Notes:

    Stop Street Harassment. "Bystander Responses". (n.d.) StopStreetHarassment.com. October 30, 2014. http://www.stopstreetharassment.org/strategies/bystander-responses/

    Pierre-Louis, Marly. "Responses to the Shit Men Say in Defense of Street Harassment". Brooklyn Movement Center. April 18, 2013. BrooklynMovementCenter.org. October 30, 2014. http://brooklynmovementcenter.org/p...shit-men-say-in-defense-of-street-harassment/

    Pederson, Sarah. "Calling Out Cat-Callers". The Siren. November 26, 2014. UNCSiren.com. October 30, 2014. http://uncsiren.com/catcalling/
     
  8. spidergoat pubic diorama Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    54,036
    The length of time in which these approaches occur is irrelevant.
     
  9. Bells Staff Member

    Messages:
    24,270
    This is where you completely miss the point.

    This is a woman walking through the city. The predetermined outcome is that she would be harassed. And she was.

    The point you absolutely missed is that it should not be a predetermined outcome. The truth of the matter is that women should be allowed to walk down the street without being harassed, without harassment being a "predetermined outcome".

    She did not wear a sign saying "please harass me" as I walk. She did not shake her tits or jiggle her bum at anyone. She simply walked.

    And you seem to believe that not only is it acceptable, but that she is to blame because she dared to show just how bad it is for women? You seem fine that harassment is a predetermined outcome. That this is normal and to you, what is not normal or acceptable is that this woman made this video.

    The clip is only garbage if you are of the camp who believes that women should be harassed and that this is the normal and natural result of simply walking down the street and that women should simply find something else to complain about.
     
    Last edited: Oct 30, 2014
  10. sculptor Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    8,476
    I do not condone harassment of anyone, male or female, old or young, of any nationality, race or creed.
    All I said was that the video clip was garbage as far as drawing any conclusive psychological inferences.
    and, therefore: The survey is also meaningless if drawn from this clip.

    incidentally
    I lean toward peer group nurture, with a smidgen of nature overlaying the peer group pressure thing.
     
  11. zgmc Registered Senior Member

    Messages:
    831
    I really don't know. I would think yes, but it may be nurture that makes it seem that way.
     
  12. Bells Staff Member

    Messages:
    24,270
    It is the OP who is trying to infer psychological inferences from the video.

    The video serves as a view, if you will, of what women have to suffer when simply walking down the street, going about their daily lives. To say that the video itself is garbage because you believe it simply seeks out a predetermined outcome is wrong. The problem with the video is that it did not have to seek out that outcome. The video shows just how and why it is predetermined that women will be harassed if they walk down the street. And that is wrong. It should not be this way.

    Women should be allowed to walk down the street without harassment being a predetermined outcome.

    More disturbingly, the woman in the video has now been threatened with rape, for having posted the video. She has received threatening emails and calls, threatening to rape her because of it. Sadly, that too is predetermined.
     
  13. sculptor Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    8,476
    Did you want to make the case that saying "how are you" can universally be construed as harassment?
     
  14. PhysBang Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    2,422
    • Please do not flame other members.
    Fuck no. You already condoned harassing women, so fuck your pathetic attempt to make yourself look like less of a piece of shit.
     
    pjdude1219 likes this.
  15. cluelusshusbund + Public Dilemma + Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    8,000
    Last edited: Oct 31, 2014
  16. James R Just this guy, you know? Staff Member

    Messages:
    39,426
    Yes, I think they are. But I think that what makes men do it is a combination of nature and nurture (as with most other complex behavioural traits), so I voted "other" in the poll.
     
  17. James R Just this guy, you know? Staff Member

    Messages:
    39,426
    sculptor,

    She had a "grump on", did she? What do you mean by that? That she was already angry before she started the experiment, and that affected the outcome? I don't see how it could have an effect unless the men who were harassing her could somehow sense the anger. So, maybe you mean that she looked grumpy as she walked down the street. Let's suppose that is true and you're not just projecting onto her. Do you think it is acceptable for men to harass grumpy-looking women as they walk down the street? Does being grumpy make them fair game? I can't really tell from what you've written. Perhaps you could list for me the circumstances under which you think that it would be acceptable for you (say) to walk silently beside a woman who is a stranger to you and happens to be walking past, for five minutes, which amounts to a physical threat.

    You think time is relevant? Tell me: at what percentage would you start to consider harassment of women walking down the street to be a problem? Would it have to happen 10% of the time? 50%? How much?

    Is it ok to harass women if you don't do it for very long? Is that it? A quick "Smile! You look grumpy. And goddamn you look hot, girl!" is just fine to direct towards a stranger, I suppose, because it only takes a second or two. Right?

    Why? Do you think those harassing men were actors? Do you think the clip isn't representative of what women get all the time in New York as they walk through the city?

    Tell me why it was worthless garbage, sculptor. Was it because it was made with a "grumpy" intent, perhaps? And does that excuse the men's behaviour?

    Do you think the guy that walked alongside her in the clip demanding that she talk to him (a complete stranger), and demanding to know why she wouldn't talk to him ("Am I too ugly for you?") does not justify her "having an attitude" towards street harassment?

    Please explain your position, sculptor. And tell me: are you one of those guys who shouts out at women on the street? If so, tell me why you think it is ok. I really want to know.
     
  18. Bells Staff Member

    Messages:
    24,270
    But that's not what happened, was it?

    You completely leave out the way in which such questions are asked, how it is asked, the intonation, the look on the guy's face, how he is looking at her. A simple sentence of "how are you" can be turned into something very suggestive.
     
  19. Bells Staff Member

    Messages:
    24,270
    Okay, lets tone it down a bit. That isn't acceptable.
     
  20. milkweed Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    1,654
    I dont consider most of what was displayed in the video as harassment.

    But on first view the man walking along side for several minutes, in real life I would have been very uncomfortable with that. However on second view, I noticed no comments were made from third parties while he was walking alongside. So I watched that again and listened to tone of voice as he acknowledged her and I wondered. Did he walk along side of her as a self appointed protector? An I'll be a nice guy and walk her through this neighborhood so shes safe? He didnt keep talking to her (like another individual looking to meet up). And I would not have been as uncomfortable with the guy wanting to meet up, as he was talking and I would have known what his motive was (and could have said Not interested).

    Videos like this dont impress me.

    And 20-30 years from now shes going to look back fondly on the days when she would turn heads, and miss those "how ya doing babe" moments.
     
  21. Enmos Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    43,184

    Please Register or Log in to view the hidden image!


    Seriously....
     
  22. milkweed Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    1,654
    um, yeah
    Seriously.
     
  23. Enmos Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    43,184
    So do you behave in the same way as those guys?
     
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page