Israeli right winger endorses one state solution!

Don't quote Jeremy Milgram as if he is representative of anybody, I'm not sure he's even considered a Rabbi...as in he never got shmicha from a respectable beit din. The guy's pretty much in line with Neturei Karta, which is entirely discredited by everyone Jewish. I remember Dovid Weiss speaking in Arizona as one extremely secular Jew screamed [exact quote] "The tribe of Judah hates you mother fucker" and the Orthodox nearby were inclined to agree.

This guy obviously fails to represent anything remnant of Torah values when he states The Jews who invest their hope in continued Jewish domination are betraying Jewish morality. In fact...I can't even count how many times it said "Drive out Cannanites" and "Smite them and drive them out". Read the first chapter of judges, it's all about smiting...in fact...kicking people out of Israel is practically the entire point of the book of Joshua.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide all adverts.

OK is the Jewish Theological Seminary in some sort of trouble with G_d (or Israel) that they're concealing? It's hard to tell from their website, but I've seen enough that I think it's fitting that I edit the reference to reflect again that Rabbi Milgrom is a real Rabbi (in the USA and Israel).

Forum of Rabbis For Human Rights
Rabbis for Human Rights (5 minute YouTube video)
Jeremy Milgrom @ livejournal.com
The Rebuilding Alliance

​

 

Log in or Sign up to hide all adverts.

Watching the R4HR video linked above, I was interested to rediscover a component of the Israeli Declaration of Independence that I had forgotten:

Things were taking a wrong turn even while this was drafted, but a lot of the above can serve as a firm foundation for a de-segregated single-state resolution of the "Arab-Israeli" conflict. It seems well worth a sincere try to me: Especially now that the Ingathering of Exiles has been such a success (for Jewish ones anyway) why shouldn't the builders of a more secure Israel apply themselves to this list with equal dedication?

 

Log in or Sign up to hide all adverts.

Conservative American Judaism is equivalent to Reform European Judaism is equivalent to Masorti Israeli Judaism....but not Daati Leumi.

Did you know a some Conservative Jewish synagogues preach that there is no God?

 

I don't think it's topical here, or that this has much to do with Rabbi Milgrom- But yes, I'll accept your assertion that rabbis can be atheists, or even a Kook. There's a lot of differing dati frum the internets, but I don't see the clear relevance of this to one-state integration of Israel (other than that the most rabid Zionist and Judeophobic/anti-semitic fringes will always hate it).

Maybe we can stay topical, even while you teach the Torah, and explain that one. I'm no Biblical scholar, but to claim Jewish domination as Jewish morality is quite something for you to claim as Torah truth. Please "enlighten" us with the basis of that (the converse of your quote in bold above).

 

This assumes that a single state would remain desegregated, which is not particularly likely.

 

I know it isn't exactly Torah, but as they say, "if at first you don't succeed... don't barricade yourself in and quit." A lot of modern nations have abolished segregation. What's keeping Israelis from respecting their Declaration of Independence?

 

Actually, they do say that: but this isn't exactly the first attempt either.

If you can get the Pat Robertson....or Jim Phelps...out of religion and politics and religiopolitics in the countries of the Middle East, then maybe.

 

They are the only 2 religious nuts left over there? Huzzah! -& I never knew they were so powerful (Rev. Pat did con my poor Kentucky Grandma out of a lot of money she couldn't afford to give him, come to think of it).

OK I know what you mean, and yes, I think it could be done (back to the DoI above).

 

The DoI?

 

The point is you're presenting three men as if they represent Israeli mindset. Israel wants a one state solution; the Palestinians to move out. However, most Israelis would settle for a 2-state solution...the issue is who gets what. That in consideration...almost NO ONE wants a 1 state solution where it's not "Israel, the Jewish state". Listen to HaTikva...http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NjfFpFW9OdA

"As long as the heart within is a Jewish soul yearning...an eye towards tzion...the hope of 2 thousand years longing to be a free nation in our own land, the land of tzion and Jerusalem, to be a free nation in our own land"

And yet you're convinced by an amateur blogger that because a self-proclaimed anti-Israeli rabbi, a liberal hilonim, and a dati leumi met to discuss a one-state secular soltuon that it's somehow the opinion of even a moderate minority of Israel.

How about...YOU get on track, or at least with the program.

 

One need only possess eyes and ears to observe the innate urge to Violent Domination that is at the Core of Jewishness. To suggest that this is anything but obvious is Mossad hasbara to demean the Palestinian Genocide and so advance the Rapacious Apartheid Entity. You'll burn in hell with Hitler and all the other Zionists for your callous embrace of Racist Infanticide.

 

I'm a fat kid who always wants an ice cream cone.

 

True we all know at this point and time a one state solution is a long way off, but as those settlements in the west bank get bigger and bigger a one state solution is going to become more and more the practical reality, at least for the west bank, Gaza and clearly be left to fend for it self.

 

so you finally admit the crux of it. the zionist/Israelis/JEwish nation doesn't want to share. they want to ethnicly cleanse palestinian of its rightful owners.

 

while that is bigotrd in the extreme their is some element of truth to it. how else can you reconcile the fact the the jews were native to palestine in antiquity but invented and invasion myth with themselves as conquerering heroes.

 

Zionist Dogs will go to any length to downplay this obvious fact, at the behest of their Mossad/CIA masters. Their weak, lying "morality" is no impediment to The Righteous.

There is no bigotry involved in observation of plane fact. It is incumbent upon The Just to reject the vile strictures of Political Correctness: they are simply another tool that the Imperialist Nazis employ to avoid The Truth and brainwash the sheeple into defending the indefensible Persecution of the Innocent. Anyone who dares speak the Truth about the Jews and their program of Satanic Racial Annihilation is relentlessly persecuted by the corrupt Nazi authorities, all while they lie through their blood-stained teeth about "free speech" and "human rights." The Righteous fear neither these snivelling bureaocrats nor the bullets and missiles of The Prime Aggressor.

More disgusting hasbara. Palestine has always belonged to the Palestinians, and no others. The Jews have always coveted their lands and so find any excuse to invade and destroy the Innocent Children of Palestine. You must purify yourself of these Mossad delusions if you wish to be anything more than an unwitting tool of the Nazi Apartheid Forces.

 

Yeah, you caught me. The Jewish nation considers its self a Jewish nation.

 

Heh.

 

Israel is not the jewish nation the jewish nation is the the jewish nation