PDA

View Full Version : Physics of snapping the fingers



dristam
03-14-09, 07:56 PM
Everyone thinks I'm nuts but I'm still clinging to the notion that (perhaps) the loud sound of snapping one's fingers results from exceeding the Speed of Sound. I've heard that the crack of a whip's tip is so caused and I think a human finger can also duplicate the feat. Naysayers mainly retort that the sound is produced by the middle finger HITTING the base of the thumb, but I don't believe it. One such naysayer told me to place a wadded napkin over the base of my thumb to deaden the sound and thus disprove my assertion. I did the test and the sound was NOT deadened, so I remain unswayed.

I figure that only a super slow-motion camera could truly pin down what velocities are being attained. I don't have the means for that. Any ideas?
:shrug:

rpenner
03-14-09, 08:17 PM
In multiple trials, placing something between finger and meaty part of thumb altered the sound. So my experiments support the no-sonic-boom theory. A laminated 3x5 card seems to increase the noise as expected by noise-upon-impact theory.

Here's a video at 2000 frames per second. You can see the meaty quiver of the sounding board base of the thumb.

http://courses.ncssm.edu/hsi/hsvideo/snap.htm

Anti-Flag
03-14-09, 09:18 PM
In multiple trials, placing something between finger and meaty part of thumb altered the sound.

Agreed, the noise comes from your finger hitting the base of the thumb. Not sure dristam how you're experiment failed this but you should repeat it.

dristam
03-15-09, 12:23 AM
Thank you for that video!

It appears to show the fingertip moving at merely 15 or 20 miles per hour, (about 2.5 inches in a hundredth of a second). Would others agree?

But I am sorely disappointed.

Oh well

draqon
03-15-09, 12:24 AM
dude, if it moved at speed of sound...you wouldnt have a finger left.

dristam
03-15-09, 01:21 AM
I'm minimally embarrassed to add that I'm still not convinced. However, I would definitely be convinced if there were such a video with a mic positioned very very near that is connected to a visualizer or oscilloscope.

Maybe it's not the movement of the middle finger but the sudden shudder of the thumbnail I dunno, I'm nuts
:shrug:

dristam
03-15-09, 01:25 AM
Nevermind, I think I'm convinced now uh maybe.
The odd noise could derive from the all-of-a-sudden shrinking orifice formed between the digits, and the bland hitting noise is thereinthrough channeled. Could be.

Oli
03-15-09, 01:27 AM
Where would the requisite energy come from to accelerate the digit(s) to sonic speed?
Could the bone structure survive the acceleration?
It is NOT a result of a sonic boom.