I don't get it. one of their big things is that the Palestinians are not a people because they are not ethnically distinct. I have on a number of occasions made the attempt to refute it by offering up the example of Switzerland, Austria, and Germany. The Swiss and Austrians are geographically and culturally distinct but not ethnically distinct(they are both ethnically German for the most part.) I say according to there logic of why the Palestinians aren't a people and therefore shouldn't be allowed to form a nation that the nations of Switzerland and Austria shouldn't exist and that they should be part of Germany. Not one pro-Israel person has ever tried to refute said logic or even rationally reply to it. In fact one of them Cheskichips claimed it was garbage and put me on his ignore list( something I feel was childish but that's a whole different thing) I mean could some please explain whats wrong with my comparison. I am comparing 2 geographically and culturally distinct but not ethnically distinct people who have their own countries to one geographically and culturally distinct but not ethnically distinct people who don't have their own country/

Look up Zionism.

Of course Palestinians should be able to form a nation.

You have a good point. Germany should annex Austria and Switzerland.

You have a good point. Germany should annex Austria and Switzerland.
haha....

shouldn't they then also take France? Franks were "Germans" .. weren't they? What about the Dutch - I mean Dutch is German. English is a Germanic language - maybe England too.

You know, this almost sounds like WWII .... no wonder Cheskichips use the good old ignore button, any more thinking and he'd have realized many Israelis are in reality German.. of a WWII mindset.

I put him on block because I was trying to make the point that the PLO organization was installed with a well documented connection to NAZI Germany, and has had leaders and mantras directly associated with Mein Kampft and other NAZI Propaganda. And I was making comparison to Infitada tactics and NAZI tactics...since the earlier came from the latter by direct translation.

While he wanted to bring up ethnic rights...

When he failed to recognize my argument in even the smallest way...I blocked him.

I put him on block because I was trying to make the point that the PLO organization was installed with a well documented connection to NAZI Germany, and has had leaders and mantras directly associated with Mein Kampft and other NAZI Propaganda. And I was making comparison to Infitada tactics and NAZI tactics...since the earlier came from the latter by direct translation.

While he wanted to bring up ethnic rights...

When he failed to recognize my argument in even the smallest way...I blocked him.

your truly are a piece of work. You were commenting on the Palestinians not being a people I refuted it and you put me on ignore. Your are a liar. In no post that i replied to were you talking about nazis.
There's no such thing as palestinian people. Never existed, it's a completely conscripted idea.

You said you don't want to debate, then you debated after that sentence...I'm confused.
You can't debate a bigot like yourself. Quit being a bigot and people will debate you.( I am sorry but claiming there is no such thing as a palestinian people is bigoted and stupid)Why? If a bunch of French people in the cajun country decided they wanted nationality...they're not a people. They were never connected before, and if they did it only because they wanted to kill the British descendants it'd be wrong.What the fuck do you mean why? They are a people plain and fucking simple. What is it with you pro-Israel fuckers and your complete lack of understanding of peoplehood. I mean shit according your logic Austria and Switzerland shouldn't be countries because their Germans. Guess what geographical distinct people have can be a distinct people.And by the way PJDude, you're now on block Reason: Too much garbage, trash day isn't until Thursday.

this was the exchange that led to you putting me on ignore. The only person ignoring an argument is you

Of course Palestinians should be able to form a nation.

And shouldn't American "rednecks" be permitted to form a nation, too? :D

Baron Max

And shouldn't American "rednecks" be permitted to form a nation, too? :D

Baron Max

Yes. Please. I want them to. And then it would be my sincere pleasure to join the military and bomb the shit out of the new Confederacy.

Yes. Please. I want them to. And then it would be my sincere pleasure to join the military and bomb the shit out of the new Confederacy.

So it's okay to bomb and blow the shit outta' people and nations that don't think, act, feel and believe the same as you? :D

Baron Max

You have a good point. Germany should annex Austria and Switzerland.

what no. that's the inverse of my argument.

And shouldn't American "rednecks" be permitted to form a nation, too? :D

Baron Max

Someone should kindly whisper to them they already are a part of one.