View Full Version : Some Problems With Atheism ( Part 2 )


RawThinkTank
03-18-04, 09:34 AM
It has been proved that God is genetically programmed in human brain. All atheist at some point will circumvent and pray due to this whether god exist or not, trust me.

I am a Rationalist and do not let myself get into cults of atheism. A new bible can be written by them on the subject as they are so attached to it and that would become a religion itself. Who knows after thousand years God will be portrayed as source of all chaos if our life. I hope instead of uniting the world it doesn’t create a global rift between believers and nons.
Since there is no evil as such in non believer they may go to any extent to propagate what they believe is perfect like Hitler but without consequence of hell in after life.

In science “The absence of evidence is not the evidence of absence.” Period; If U don’t believe that then U r irrational. It will be very sad if people discover after their death that they are in heaven and they were wrong all their life; What a waste ?

Personally I choose when to pray and when to not, when I become very sure that the unpleasant things are absolutely out of my capacity to correct even though it’s a possibility, then I pray. Hey anybody has a problem with that. We have a right to pray damit. But then those blind believer never curse God for the unfair world of his and that p***** me off.

Did u ever realize the bigger picture, religion is just something that is part of evolution, look at it in that perspective and U will realize nature in its role. We are result of that evolution; in the phase where we have started questioning it without realizing that.

Ozymandias
03-18-04, 09:43 AM
Should this go in Religion?

cosmictraveler
03-18-04, 10:07 AM
RawThinkTank......... What about Buddhists, Shintoists, Communists, and others that don't have Gods that they worship? Since they weren't "programed" from birth to believe in any God how can you say such things?

spidergoat
03-18-04, 11:24 AM
Perhaps praying has a benefit that has nothing to do with god, but with the power of positive thinking, quieting the chaotic mind, or a placebo effect.

In science, it is important to keep an open mind, but they also subscribe to the notion of occam's razor- not to multiply explanations unnecessarily. They look for explanations inherent in the systems they observe. Since god cannot be observed, directly or indirectly, it is an unnecessary complication. Not that the absence of god can be proved conclusively.

There is, in the east, the concept of Tao. This is explained as the principle in the universe that leads to harmonious balance. It is very different than the concept of god, in that it is seen as passive in nature, inherent within the basic structure of things. Taoists are atheist, as well as buddhists, and many others, you can't prove conclusively that they are wrong either.

As you suggest, religion had an important evolutionary role in the past of maintaining social order, a kind of intellectual software that gave people hope in an uncertain world. But the evolution of thought continues, and new ideas generated by science challenge the old orthodoxies.

Welcome to sciforums, do not underestimate the philosophical sophistication of the members here, and please avoid text messaging abbreviations.

Ozymandias
03-18-04, 06:36 PM
and please avoid text messaging abbreviations.

Huzzah to that. It detracts from the seriousness of your message and can make you seem much less mature than you are.

Q25
03-18-04, 10:01 PM
It has been proved that God is genetically programmed in human brain.
oh really?proved how and by whom?

All atheist at some point will circumvent and pray due to this whether god exist or not, trust me.
and you know this how?

I am a Rationalist and do not let myself get into cults of atheism.
atheism is NOT a cult,its a lack of belief in gods and supernatural.
see www.atheists.org

If U don’t believe that then U r irrational. It will be very sad if people discover after their death that they are in heaven and they were wrong all their life; What a waste ?
and if you believe in something that you have no way of proving it exists makes sense right? :rolleyes:
btw do you believe in Santa claus,leprechauns,tooth fairy,devils and angels?

Personally I choose when to pray and when to not, when I become very sure that the unpleasant things are absolutely out of my capacity to correct We have a right to pray damit.
pray all you want,who gives a shit,if you think there is some supreme being siting on the cloud who will change your fate if you pray hard enough,you are so mentaly unevolved its rather quite sad.

Did u ever realize the bigger picture, religion is just something that is part of evolution, look at it in that perspective and U will realize nature in its role. We are result of that evolution; in the phase where we have started questioning it without realizing that.
thats true,now how about if you evolve just a litle bit like the rest of us.
www.thewaronfaith.com

give man a fish and he will eat for a day,give man religion and he'll starve while praying for food!

this is how your religion looks from atheist pov;
www.jhuger.com/kisshank.mv

Silverback
03-18-04, 10:38 PM
Q25 that last link is freakin hysterical!

Thanks! :D

Dr Lou Natic
03-18-04, 11:32 PM
Hahaha that was really great:D

Ozymandias
03-18-04, 11:34 PM
I'm printing that out. These pamphlets will go to good use. :D

spuriousmonkey
03-19-04, 01:55 AM
It has been proved that God is genetically programmed in human brain.


that must have been either a nature or a science paper then. Maybe you could give a reference. I can't find it with Pubmed.

Period; If U don?t believe that then U r irrational. It will be very sad if people discover after their death that they are in heaven and they were wrong all their life; What a waste ?


Wouldn't it be more rational to think these devil worshippers go to hell instead of heaven?

gendanken
03-19-04, 03:36 PM
RawthinkTank:
Did u ever realize the bigger picture, religion is just something that is part of evolution, look at it in that perspective and U will realize nature in its role. We are result of that evolution; in the phase where we have started questioning it without realizing that.
Then why the hell do you pray then?

Why do we find you with your head down mostly when you feel things are so unpleasent and, I quote,.....".... absolutely out of my capacity to correct even though it’s a possibility".?

Answer: unstable, insatiable WEAKNESS. Your locus of control lies eleshwere.
Now fix your horrible spelling.

Cosmic:
RawThinkTank......... What about Buddhists, Shintoists, Communists, and others that don't have Gods that they worship? Since they weren't "programed" from birth to believe in any God how can you say such things?
Buddhism is dripping with mythology, much like any other religion. There are if I remember correctly, 12 or 14 classes of god the highest being the Brahmas.

There's a reason why men, all men of all walks of life, take to mythology and its centered on the temporal lobes.

shrubby pegasus
03-19-04, 03:52 PM
maybe rawthinktank got his proof from marco's thread about proving god exists. he really put together an ironclad proof and i could easily see how this absurdity could be extrapolated from that pile of nonsense.

ConsequentAtheist
03-19-04, 08:33 PM
It has been proved that God is genetically programmed in human brain.No, it is not. See, for example, Is God in your brain? (http://www.nmsr.org/r_s_0802.htm).

mountainhare
03-19-04, 09:27 PM
give man a fish and he will eat for a day,give man religion and he'll starve while praying for food!

HEHEHE!
I'll have to remember that one.

Dreamwalker
03-20-04, 07:33 AM
Quote:
It has been proved that God is genetically programmed in human brain.

Yeah right, I can also prove that god is a pain in the ass, but does it make him real? As for me, I never had the urge to pray because I do not believe in any religion and the various gods listed in these convictions. :bugeye:

RawThinkTank
03-21-04, 09:49 AM
I want to know about people who were brought up by Atheist parents. Logically if atheism is so superior then those people should be next step in human evolution. And hence most superiorly capable people today must be atheist in ratio compared to theist, if not then …..

“What about Buddhists, Shintoists, Communists, and others that don't have Gods that they worship” , here Important question is, do they worship anything? if they do then lets not continue discussing about those naïve souls instead lets evolve in the direction of the statement “The absence of evidence is not the evidence of absence.” which is used in discussions of alien life, and here for GOD.

Can atheism be defined as deficiency of ability to believe in some possibilities? One of the problems is atheist look at theist as some shit, instead of concentrating on their moral and ethical values defined by their religions.

To believe or not to believe is our decision but that has nothing to do with our urge to pray, its hardwired in our brain, if it is not then it is a possibility that these people had a completely different route of evolution or may be they are aliens but they are not aware as their forefathers came here hundreds of years ago OR they are simply denying the truth in order to convince themselves to continue evil as there wont be a afterlife. Yes there is another possibility that they are mutant who lack some of the genes that make us humans.

Persol
03-21-04, 10:05 AM
Logically if atheism is so superior then those people should be next step in human evolution. You've never taken a class on logic or biology, have you?

SkinWalker
03-21-04, 10:19 AM
Can atheism be defined as deficiency of ability to believe in some possibilities? One of the problems is atheist look at theist as some shit, instead of concentrating on their moral and ethical values defined by their religions.

You are making a lot of a priori assumptions without relying on any empirical data to back it up. It is true that there are some atheists who are actively opposed to theism, but I think it more likely that the vast majority are never heard from and simply choose not to "believe" in traditional human superstitions.

To believe or not to believe is our decision but that has nothing to do with our urge to pray, its hardwired in our brain, if it is not then it is a possibility that these people had a completely different route of evolution or may be they are aliens

You still haven't cited any sources to this claim, but you have changed from "it is proven" to "if not, then it is a possibility." It is true that there have been several works that suggested that religion (or more specifically, the predisposition to believe) is "hardwired" to the brain. Pascal Boyer and Vilayanur S. Ramachandran are two: the former set out to do so, the latter noted a region of the brain that, when disconnected or affected, influanced religious belief.

But these two are far from providing conclusive proof that "religion is hardwired" in the brain.

OR they are simply denying the truth in order to convince themselves to continue evil as there wont be a afterlife. Yes there is another possibility that they are mutant who lack some of the genes that make us humans.

Very speculative without supporting evidence. Not to mention it shows a clear bias against atheism for not willing to share your beliefs.

I'd be willing to bet that if a study was conducted, atheists would be found to have and maintain higher moral standards than the average theist. This, I would attribute to the world rejection and salvation motifs found in post-axial religions. To be blunt: this life is worthless, its the next that matters. Whereas atheists live with the assumption that this is all you get: therefore, it pays to do it right. storm front.

st0rmfr0nt

John Connellan
03-21-04, 10:28 AM
It has been proved that God is genetically programmed in human brain.
Its impossible to prove anything!

ConsequentAtheist
03-21-04, 01:28 PM
I want to know about people who were brought up by Atheist parents. Logically if atheism is so superior then those people should be next step in human evolution.You clearly understand neither logic nor evolution.

Persol
03-21-04, 01:30 PM
You clearly understand neither logic nor evolution.Wow, that was scary.

ConsequentAtheist
03-21-04, 01:36 PM
And that was inane. Next?

Persol
03-21-04, 01:43 PM
You missed my point (and my post).You've never taken a class on logic or biology, have you?

ConsequentAtheist
03-21-04, 02:07 PM
My apologies!

Katazia
03-21-04, 08:55 PM
Raw,

“The absence of evidence is not the evidence of absence.”But yes it is. The continuing absence of evidence for gods after thousands of years of baseless claims is indeed very good evidence of their absence.

What you really mean is that absence of evidence is not proof of absence, and that is a quite different issue.

Kat

Katazia
03-21-04, 09:02 PM
Raw,

Did u ever realize the bigger picture, religion is just something that is part of evolution, look at it in that perspective and U will realize nature in its role. We are result of that evolution; in the phase where we have started questioning it without realizing that.Quite right, and in our current primitive state and ignorance religion was an inevitable event. As we gradually replace ignorance and religious superstitions with knowledge then we will be able to evolve forward and most certainly away from religion if we are to survive as a species.

Kat

antifreeze
03-21-04, 09:38 PM
We have a right to pray damit
i don't think so, but that is a topic for another thread.
atheism is NOT a cult, its a lack of belief in gods and supernatural.
is that right? i thought that atheism was more of an active disbelief in god, rather than a passive lack of belief.
give man a fish and he will eat for a day, give man religion and he'll starve while praying for food!
wow. that was stupendous. i fell out of my chair laughing.
instead of concentrating on their moral and ethical values defined by their religions.
wholly hell! i will grant you that religion does contain morals within it. however, what about the concept of your sins being forgiven you once you are absolved by a guy in a white collar? there are actually some decent concepts in that bible of yours. it is only a shame i do not see more christians following them. furthermore, if religion is supposed to teach people how to act, why do people confess their sins rather than not sinning in the first place?

Mystech
03-22-04, 02:28 AM
Its impossible to prove anything!

Oh yeah? Prove it.

RawThinkTank
03-23-04, 08:06 AM
Humans pray god, so can we count those who don’t as one of us? if not then should they be striped off all human rights ?

Lets see what Atheist are made of, because we must know who is right. Behold, Lets destroy here the foundations of atheism. 5, 4, 3, 2, 1, go

If they consider themselves so superior then how come they are so sure that they are incapable of one day create god themselves, if they do then god what will happen if god travels back in time here ?

I am not aware of any aliens who must have already created god in past, if they did then is there a god ?

If we continue to evolve they why is it so difficult for them to believe that after a zillion years we may have surpassed capabilities of god, if we can then why cant aliens from the past or future ?

Are they going to deny all these possibilities; because digital games in which we can play gods are already in existence which shows the direction we are heading to; If life is part of universe then why cant they comprehend gods possibility in it.

What makes them so sure that god did not created each one of them, we are all individuals due to genetic mutations, evolution is a result of random mutations, how are they sure that god cannot control random events in universe which can have no law to define them; When we create a virtual world we program history in it too, so why cant god create evolution for creating us. That makes biblical sense.

Being a Rationalist, I don’t like the way some are trying to inflate their ego here.
Rationalism can go beyond the barriers of beliefs and rule out any impossibilities unlike atheism, hence Rationalists are the logical next step in evolution.

spuriousmonkey
03-23-04, 08:21 AM
If they consider themselves so superior then how come they are so sure that they are incapable of one day create god themselves, if they do then god what will happen if god travels back in time here ?

Would it be too much to ask you to make some kind of sentence that makes sense?




I am not aware of any aliens who must have already created god in past, if they did then is there a god ?

I believe this world must be teeming with gods considering the quite large amounts of religions; probably as many as there are people.



If we continue to evolve they why is it so difficult for them to believe that after a zillion years we may have surpassed capabilities of god, if we can then why cant aliens from the past or future ?

They wouldn't be supernatural if they had evolved now would they?


Are they going to deny all these possibilities; because digital games in which we can play gods are already in existence which shows the direction we are heading to; If life is part of universe then why cant they comprehend gods possibility in it.

Why can't you understand that this universe doesn't need a god to be explained?



What makes them so sure that god did not created each one of them, we are all individuals due to genetic mutations, evolution is a result of random mutations, how are they sure that god cannot control random events in universe which can have no law to define them; When we create a virtual world we program history in it too, so why cant god create evolution for creating us. That makes biblical sense.

Didn't know that the bible makes sense. But we might not want to believe that god is behind all randomness because it doesn't really bring anything to the world. He is invisible, his actions are invisible, he is not present because he is invisible.
Uh...maybe he doesn't exist?



Being a Rationalist, I don?t like the way some are trying to inflate their ego here.
Rationalism can go beyond the barriers of beliefs and rule out any impossibilities unlike atheism, hence Rationalists are the logical next step in evolution.

Those two sentences were devoid of logic and rationalism I'm afraid.

gendanken
03-23-04, 08:59 PM
Connellan:
Its impossible to prove anything!
Guaging from differences in seizures based on what part of the brain is impacted, I assure you there is plenty of reason to read up on Neurotheology.

You sex, eat, starve, love, and hate with your mind so no reason to think the gods are immune to our neurons. Anway-

Rathinkitank:

If they consider themselves so superior then how come they are so sure that they are incapable of one day create god themselves, if they do then god what will happen if god travels back in time here ?

You will forever and a fucking day go on asking your 'why nots' about atheists- people as religious as you- without realizing the only difference between the both of you: to an atheist, God, Marduk, and Allah are inconsequential.

They simply don't matter.

rainbow__princess_4
03-24-04, 12:25 AM
But atheists do have a religion. They're atheists. You (original person) said that it is human nature to have a faith/beliefs well atheists do. They believe we just are, stuff is cool and that we become plant food when we die. Life is worth living and death is natural. They ARE beliefs. I am aware that not all Atheists feel the same, but all do have some kind of belief. I am sure many ppl say they're atheists because they're just so unsure that they don't want to think anymore.

spuriousmonkey
03-24-04, 01:53 AM
But atheists do have a religion. They're atheists. You (original person) said that it is human nature to have a faith/beliefs well atheists do. They believe we just are, stuff is cool and that we become plant food when we die. Life is worth living and death is natural. They ARE beliefs. I am aware that not all Atheists feel the same, but all do have some kind of belief. I am sure many ppl say they're atheists because they're just so unsure that they don't want to think anymore.

Religion embraces the supernatural. That is what defines religion, not that people merely have opinions on how the world works.

gendanken
03-24-04, 04:22 PM
Rainbow:
But atheists do have a religion. They're atheists
Exactly, but not all.

Only those that have no other reason to contest the 'gods' other than defiance are religious in ther very opposition. If on can seriously divorce themselves from the subjective, take the matter into hand and then examine it like all specimens should be then you're halfway there. Completion comes by supplement the inquiry with one's own thoughts and opinions and through sheer discipline then would the atheism there not be a religion. Religion is the defence or praise of something withouth knowing shit about it.

This includes Goths.

Monkey:
Religion embraces the supernatural. That is what defines religion, not that people merely have opinions on how the world works.
But those that hold those opinions and defend them in their lazyness are

spuriousmonkey
03-25-04, 03:36 AM
But those that hold those opinions and defend them in their lazyness are

are what? lazy? prejudiced?

I fail to see how having an opinion and defending it, is the same as having a religion.

You would need to elaborate on this before I could understand this.