Modes of Modality; a philosophical dialogue of (possibly) informative proportions

Discussion in 'Free Thoughts' started by Celpha Fiael, Oct 29, 2008.

  1. Celpha Fiael within reason, I am superman Registered Senior Member

    Messages:
    383
    In case you'd rather see a video performance of it:

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_YskIqxFhHE


    Here's the script:

    --Scene--

    A job interview at the Department of Semantics between character 1 and character 2...



    1: (reading a document) "It says here you are certain that you're right for the job."

    2: "That's right."

    1: "Well what exactly do you mean by 'certain'?"

    2: "Certainty is the absence of possibility."

    1: "Really? Are you certain about that?"

    2: "That's certainly a possibility."

    1: "A certain possibility? How can you possibly say that?"

    2: "Because it wasn't certain that I would say that."

    1: "But wasn't it possible that you saying that could have been a certainty?"

    2: "Certainly."

    1: "Didn't you mean to say 'possibly' just now?"

    2: "I dunno, possibly."

    1: "I'm fairly certain you did."

    2: "One can't be 'fairly certain', that's not possible."

    1: "So then that must be certain?"

    2: "I am uncertain about that."

    1: "You are impossible!"

    2: "I am most certainly am not!"

    1: "Now you tell me you're uncertain about what uncertainty is."

    2: "But I am certain of what is not possible."

    1: "But if you are uncertain about what certainty is, then how can you possibly be certain of what's not possible?"

    2: "I guess it's possible that my uncertainty makes that impossible. But if that truly is possible, then you can't possibly be certain about your statement either."

    1: "Could it be possible that every statement of certainty is subject to such uncertainty?"

    2: "It's not impossible."

    1: "So...it's possible that certainty is impossible?"

    2: "Isn't that what I originally said?"

    1: "Ah, certainly!"

    2: "Exactly."

    1: "You sir, are hired!"

    2: "Excellent."

    1: "...possibly."


    --End--
     
    Last edited: Oct 30, 2008

Share This Page