Tiassa
03-12-08, 09:28 AM
I think it's sad when someone I consider a national treasure actually comes from another country. Thus, I should congratulate my British neighbors (the lousy bastards!) regarding Mr. Mark Steel.
And here's the thing. When I first saw the Lectures, I was stunned. There's nothing like them on American television. And now, reading his latest column for The Independent, it strikes me that there is a tremendous gap that, frankly, shames me as an American.
See, the thing is that no American can stand so well against jingoism in this age of rising nationalism in large part because, well, the audience won't have it.
For instance, American news consumers would absolutely flip if they encountered the equivalent of this:
The reason anyone who tries to define "Britishness" gets in a muddle must be because there's hardly anything that unites everyone who's British. And while there are behavioural traits that are typically British, you can hardly insist all immigrants have to adopt them to be considered a citizen. Otherwise you'll have citizenship lessons in which an instructor shows an England football match to a group of Somalians and says slowly "Now all together – 'Lam-pard and Gerr-ard, they can't play together - it's OBVIOUS.' Follow that with a deep sigh, then a muttered 'hopeless'. Well done, you'll soon be ready to go to a packed pub on the night of a qualifying match for your field work." Or you could have a question that asks: "Name five situations in which it would be suitable to stare blankly and mutter the phrase 'fucking Ada'."
(Steel (http://www.independent.co.uk/opinion/commentators/mark-steel/mark-steel-lets-be-modern-and-swear-an-oath-to-the-monarchy-794428.html))
Seriously, put that on the op-ed page of the Flyover Tribune, or even the New York Times, and Americans would choke on themselves.
____________________
Notes:
Steel, Mark. "Mark Steel: Let's be modern and swear an oath to the monarchy". The Independent. March 12, 2008. http://www.independent.co.uk/opinion/commentators/mark-steel/mark-steel-lets-be-modern-and-swear-an-oath-to-the-monarchy-794428.html
And here's the thing. When I first saw the Lectures, I was stunned. There's nothing like them on American television. And now, reading his latest column for The Independent, it strikes me that there is a tremendous gap that, frankly, shames me as an American.
See, the thing is that no American can stand so well against jingoism in this age of rising nationalism in large part because, well, the audience won't have it.
For instance, American news consumers would absolutely flip if they encountered the equivalent of this:
The reason anyone who tries to define "Britishness" gets in a muddle must be because there's hardly anything that unites everyone who's British. And while there are behavioural traits that are typically British, you can hardly insist all immigrants have to adopt them to be considered a citizen. Otherwise you'll have citizenship lessons in which an instructor shows an England football match to a group of Somalians and says slowly "Now all together – 'Lam-pard and Gerr-ard, they can't play together - it's OBVIOUS.' Follow that with a deep sigh, then a muttered 'hopeless'. Well done, you'll soon be ready to go to a packed pub on the night of a qualifying match for your field work." Or you could have a question that asks: "Name five situations in which it would be suitable to stare blankly and mutter the phrase 'fucking Ada'."
(Steel (http://www.independent.co.uk/opinion/commentators/mark-steel/mark-steel-lets-be-modern-and-swear-an-oath-to-the-monarchy-794428.html))
Seriously, put that on the op-ed page of the Flyover Tribune, or even the New York Times, and Americans would choke on themselves.
____________________
Notes:
Steel, Mark. "Mark Steel: Let's be modern and swear an oath to the monarchy". The Independent. March 12, 2008. http://www.independent.co.uk/opinion/commentators/mark-steel/mark-steel-lets-be-modern-and-swear-an-oath-to-the-monarchy-794428.html